Filed under Focus and procrastination · 10 min read

Structured procrastination: John Perry's trick for getting things done by avoiding something else

Structured procrastination, John Perry's Ig Nobel-winning idea, in plain steps: put a big, vague-deadline task on top of your list and get the useful stuff below it done as a way of avoiding it. How to set it up, a worked example, a copyable list, how it differs from productive procrastination, what the research says, and when it backfires.

By the HourMaxxing team · Published · 10 sources · how we cite

In 1996, a Stanford philosophy professor named John Perry had papers to grade, textbook orders to fill out, a grant proposal to referee and dissertation drafts to read. So he wrote an essay instead. It opened by admitting he was writing it as a way of not doing all of those things.

That essay, “How to Procrastinate and Still Get Things Done,” gave a name to something most procrastinators already do: structured procrastination. Fifteen years later it won him the 2011 Ig Nobel Prize in Literature. The idea is simple, a little silly, and useful if you set it up right. This guide covers what structured procrastination is, how to set it up step by step, a worked example, a copyable list, how it differs from productive procrastination, what the research says, and when it backfires.

What is structured procrastination?

Structured procrastination is a way of arranging your to-do list so that putting off one task gets other useful tasks done. Perry’s starting observation is that procrastinators almost never do nothing. They sharpen pencils, garden, or draw a diagram of how they’ll reorganize their files someday. They do those things because they’re a way of not doing something more important.

His essay puts it like this: the procrastinator “can be motivated to do difficult, timely and important tasks, as long as these tasks are a way of not doing something more important.”

So you build the list on purpose:

  • On top: one or two tasks that seem to have a clear deadline (but really don’t) and seem awfully important (but really aren’t). Perry’s own example was an overdue essay for a philosophy collection, eleven months late. When he finally apologized to the editor, it turned out he wasn’t much further behind than the other contributors.
  • Below: real, worthwhile tasks that do have to happen. Grading, replying, filing, fixing.

Then you let yourself procrastinate on the top item, and the lower ones get done as the escape route.

Perry also warns against the obvious fix, cutting your list down to only a few things. If the only tasks left are the scary important ones, the only way to avoid them is to do nothing at all, which is how you end up on the couch. A procrastinator needs something to run toward.

He’s open that this takes some self-deception, calling it “a pyramid scheme” you run on yourself. You have to treat the top task as urgent while knowing, somewhere, that it can wait. His argument is that procrastinators are already good at fooling themselves, so they might as well point that skill somewhere useful.

Where it came from

The essay first ran in The Chronicle of Higher Education on February 23, 1996, and now lives at structuredprocrastination.com under the title “Structured Procrastination.” It opens with a line from the humorist Robert Benchley, from Chips off the Old Benchley (1949): “anyone can do any amount of work, provided it isn’t the work he is supposed to be doing at that moment.” That’s why “Robert Benchley structured procrastination” shows up in searches.

The Ig Nobel citation in 2011 summed it up as: “To be a high achiever, always work on something important, using it as a way to avoid doing something that’s even more important.” In 2012 Perry turned the essay into a short book, The Art of Procrastination: A Guide to Effective Dawdling, Lollygagging and Postponing, which adds chapters on perfectionism, to-do lists and working with people who don’t procrastinate.

Terence Tao’s “worse task” version

People also search “Terence Tao structured procrastination.” The mathematician didn’t write about Perry’s method, but on episode 472 of the Lex Fridman Podcast, Fridman described a version he’d picked up from Tao: when you really don’t want to do something, imagine a task you want to do even less, and then do the first one as a way of avoiding the second. Tao agreed, and said a lot of getting hard work done is psychology, tricking yourself into thinking it’s feasible.

It’s the same move as Perry’s, done in your head instead of on paper. Perry’s version has the advantage that the “worse” task is real, so the trick keeps working when you see through it.

How to use structured procrastination, step by step

Perry’s essay is more of an observation than a method. Here’s how we’d turn it into a setup you can use this week.

  1. Write everything down. Do a quick brain dump so you’re working from a full list, not the three things you remember.
  2. Pick the decoy. Choose one task for the top that feels big and important but has no hard consequence this week. A long-term writing project, a big reorganization, “learn Spanish,” “finally sort the photo library.” Perry’s book suggests “Learn Chinese” as a classic.
  3. Check the decoy is safe. Ask: if this sits untouched for two weeks, does anyone get hurt, fined, failed or fired? If yes, it doesn’t belong in the decoy slot. It’s a real priority, and the ABCDE method or the Eisenhower matrix is the better tool for it.
  4. Fill the list below with real work. Put three to six concrete tasks under the decoy, things that matter and have a clear finish line: “send the invoice,” “do problem set 4,” “call the dentist.” Vague items like “admin” don’t work as escape routes, because you can’t start them.
  5. Make the useful escape the easy escape. Procrastination goes to whatever’s nearest. Keep this list on paper next to you and the phone in another room, so when you flinch away from the decoy, the next thing you see is item 2.
  6. Rotate the decoy. Once a decoy stops feeling heavy, or a real deadline appears for it, swap it out. Perry’s trick for his old essay was to wait until something even bigger landed on top, and then he got to work on the essay as a way of avoiding the new thing.

The point is to stop treating your procrastination as a moral failure for a minute and treat it like the weather. It’s going to happen. You’re deciding where it lands.

A structured procrastination example

Here’s a grad student’s week, before and after.

Before: “finish thesis chapter 2” is the only thing on the list, because everything else feels too small to bother writing down. Every work session starts with opening the chapter, feeling sick, and checking the news. By Friday, the chapter has 200 new words and nothing else got done either.

After:

Top (decoy): restructure chapter 2 and rewrite the literature review

  1. Grade 12 lab reports (due Monday)
  2. Email the lab manager about dataset access
  3. Make the figures for Thursday’s group meeting
  4. Return the three overdue library books
  5. Do the reading for Wednesday’s seminar

The chapter is still the thing being avoided. But now every time the student flinches away from it, the escape is grading, the figures or the email. By Friday, all five lower tasks are done. And the chapter? It got two hours on Thursday night, as a way of not starting the conference abstract their advisor mentioned that afternoon.

That last part is the trick working as designed. The decoy gets done when a newer, bigger decoy shows up.

A copyable structured procrastination list

Copy this into a notes app or onto a sticky note. Fill the top slot last, after the safety check.

Structured procrastination list for the week of ____________

TOP (the decoy: feels big, can safely wait 2 weeks)
  ________________________________________
  Safety check: if this waits 2 weeks, does anyone get hurt,
  fined, failed or fired?  [ ] No, it's a safe decoy

BELOW (real work with a clear finish line)
[ ] ________________________________________
[ ] ________________________________________
[ ] ________________________________________
[ ] ________________________________________
[ ] ________________________________________

Next decoy waiting in the wings:
  ________________________________________

Structured procrastination vs productive procrastination

Productive procrastination means avoiding one task by doing other useful things: answering email instead of writing the report, cleaning the kitchen instead of studying, redesigning your Notion setup instead of using it. Searches like “procrastinating by doing other tasks” are describing the same thing.

Structured procrastination is a deliberate version of it. The difference is who picks the tasks:

Productive procrastinationStructured procrastination
What gets avoidedWhatever feels worst right now, often the real priorityA decoy you chose because it can safely wait
What gets done insteadWhatever is easiest and nearestReal tasks you put on the list on purpose
Real deadlinesOften slipKept out of the decoy slot
Feels likeBusy, then guiltyBusy, and mostly fine

Is productive procrastination bad?

It depends on what’s being skipped. The research on picking easy work over important work isn’t kind to it.

In a 2018 set of experiments, Meng Zhu, Yang Yang and Christopher Hsee found what they called the mere urgency effect: people chose tasks that only looked urgent (a short window to finish) over tasks with bigger payoffs, even when the bigger payoff was obvious. Diwas KC, Bradley Staats, Maryam Kouchaki and Francesca Gino (2020) looked at emergency doctors and found that on busy shifts they tended to pick easier cases first. It felt productive, and after adjusting for case difficulty their throughput was worse.

So productive procrastination is a problem when the avoided task is the one with a real deadline or a person waiting on it. Clearing your inbox while a client report is two days late is still procrastination, with a nicer cover story. When the avoided task really can wait, getting the dishes and the invoices done instead is a good trade.

Productive procrastination with ADHD

“Productive procrastination ADHD” is one of the most common versions of the search, and the pattern is familiar: you sit down to do the hard thing and somehow end up reorganizing your desk drawer or researching the perfect planner app. Planning is the favorite disguise. Our time blocking guide has a section on when making the plan becomes the procrastination, and the task paralysis guide covers the freeze that often sits underneath.

Does structured procrastination work?

Nobody has studied it. We couldn’t find a single trial or survey of Perry’s method, and Perry himself never claimed it was science. It’s a philosopher’s observation about his own habits, written with tongue in cheek. Treat it as a trick worth testing.

What research does support is the mechanism underneath.

Procrastination is mostly about mood. Fuschia Sirois and Timothy Pychyl (2013) describe procrastination as giving priority to short-term mood repair: the task makes you feel anxious or bored, switching to something else makes that feeling stop right now, and the cost lands on your future self. If that’s right, you’ll switch to almost anything that feels less bad than the dreaded task. Structured procrastination just makes sure some of those “anything”s are useful.

What predicts procrastination. Piers Steel’s 2007 meta-analysis pooled 691 correlations and found the strongest predictors were how unpleasant the task feels, how far away the payoff is, low confidence that you can do it well, and impulsiveness. Perry’s lower tasks score well on all of those: they’re smaller, closer and easier to feel capable at. That’s part of why they’re easier to start.

The “active procrastination” debate. In 2005, Angela Hsin Chun Chu and Jin Nam Choi surveyed 230 Canadian undergraduates and described a group they called active procrastinators: people who delay on purpose because they like working under pressure. On most measures, including grades, they looked more like non-procrastinators than like regular procrastinators. The study was a one-time self-report survey of students, so it can’t show cause and effect. Later, Shamarukh Chowdhury and Timothy Pychyl (2018) argued the idea doesn’t hold together and that what Chu and Choi measured is better called purposeful delay than procrastination.

That debate is a useful line for structured procrastination too. When you choose a decoy that can safely wait, you’re doing something close to purposeful delay. When you tell yourself the report with a Friday deadline is a “decoy,” you’re doing regular procrastination with a nicer name.

What we can’t tell you: whether structured procrastination helps most people, how long it keeps working once you know the trick, or whether it beats a straight 5-minute unstick script. Try it for two weeks and check what actually got done.

When structured procrastination backfires

  • A real deadline sits in the decoy slot. This is the big one. The method only works if the top task can safely wait. Run the two-week safety check every time you pick one.
  • The lower tasks are too easy. If the escape routes are “check email” and “tidy desk,” you get the busy feeling without the useful output. Make at least half the lower tasks real work with a finish line.
  • The decoy never moves. Some decoys should eventually get done. If your thesis has been the decoy for six months, it isn’t a decoy anymore. Give it a real deadline, a time block and maybe a body double, and pick a new decoy.
  • Other people are waiting on you. Perry’s examples were tasks where his lateness cost almost nobody anything. If a teammate is blocked by it, move it off the top and treat it as a priority.
  • It feeds guilt. If you feel awful about the decoy every day, the trick isn’t working for you. Some people do better with a plain prioritized list like the ABCDE method and no self-deception at all.

Structured procrastination with ADHD

The appeal for ADHD readers is that structured procrastination works with the urge to switch instead of fighting it. You’re not forcing yourself to stay on the hardest task. You’re making sure the switch lands somewhere useful. A few adjustments help:

  • Keep the list short and on paper. Three to five lower tasks you can see at a glance work better than a long list in an app you have to open.
  • Make every lower task concrete. “Email Jo about the March invoice” is an escape route. “Admin” is a fog.
  • Be strict about the decoy check. Time blindness makes “this can wait” feel true right up until it isn’t. If there’s any real date attached, it’s not a decoy. Our guide to time blindness has more on why deadlines sneak up.
  • Pair it with a timer. Give each lower task a Pomodoro round so the escape doesn’t turn into a three-hour side quest.

This is a planning trick, not treatment. If putting things off is affecting work, school or relationships most days, that’s worth raising with a doctor.

Sources

  • Perry, J. (1996, February 23). How to procrastinate and still get things done. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Republished as “Structured Procrastination,” https://structuredprocrastination.com/ (accessed November 17, 2026).
  • Perry, J. (2012). The Art of Procrastination: A Guide to Effective Dawdling, Lollygagging and Postponing. Workman.
  • Stanford Humanities Center. (2011, September 28). 15 years after an essay on procrastination, a philosopher wins an Ig Nobel. https://shc.stanford.edu/stanford-humanities-center/news/15-years-after-essay-procrastination-philosopher-wins-ig-nobel-0.
  • Fridman, L. (Host). Terence Tao: Hardest problems in mathematics, physics and the future of AI (No. 472). Lex Fridman Podcast.
  • Sirois, F., & Pychyl, T. (2013). Procrastination and the priority of short-term mood regulation: Consequences for future self. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 7(2), 115-127. https://doi.org/10.1111/spc3.12011.
  • Steel, P. (2007). The nature of procrastination: A meta-analytic and theoretical review of quintessential self-regulatory failure. Psychological Bulletin, 133(1), 65-94. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.133.1.65.
  • Chu, A. H. C., & Choi, J. N. (2005). Rethinking procrastination: Positive effects of “active” procrastination behavior on attitudes and performance. The Journal of Social Psychology, 145(3), 245-264. https://doi.org/10.3200/SOCP.145.3.245-264.
  • Chowdhury, S., & Pychyl, T. A. (2018). A critique of the construct validity of active procrastination. Personality and Individual Differences, 120, 7-12. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.paid.2017.08.016.
  • Zhu, M., Yang, Y., & Hsee, C. K. (2018). The mere urgency effect. Journal of Consumer Research, 45(3), 673-690. https://doi.org/10.1093/jcr/ucy008.
  • KC, D. S., Staats, B. R., Kouchaki, M., & Gino, F. (2020). Task selection and workload: A focus on completing easy tasks hurts performance. Management Science, 66(10), 4397-4416. https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2019.3419.

FAQ

What is structured procrastination?

Structured procrastination is a way to get useful work done while you procrastinate. You keep a list with a big task on top that seems important and seems to have a deadline, and real, worthwhile tasks below it. Because procrastinators rarely do nothing, you end up doing the lower tasks as a way of not doing the top one. The philosopher John Perry described it in a 1996 essay.

Who came up with structured procrastination?

John Perry, a philosophy professor at Stanford, in an essay first published in The Chronicle of Higher Education on February 23, 1996, as 'How to Procrastinate and Still Get Things Done', later republished as 'Structured Procrastination'. It won him the 2011 Ig Nobel Prize in Literature, and he expanded it into a short book, The Art of Procrastination (2012). His essay opens with a line from the humorist Robert Benchley: anyone can do any amount of work, provided it isn't the work he is supposed to be doing at that moment.

What is an example of structured procrastination?

A student puts 'rewrite the thesis introduction' at the top of the list. It feels huge and the deadline is fuzzy. Below it are the week's problem set, an email to the lab about data access and a library return. Avoiding the introduction, the student finishes all three. The introduction gets its turn later, when something even bigger lands on top.

What is productive procrastination?

Productive procrastination means avoiding one task by doing other useful things, like cleaning, answering email or reorganizing your notes. Structured procrastination is a deliberate version of it: you choose what sits on top and what sits below, so the avoidance lands on work that matters instead of whatever is easiest.

Is productive procrastination bad?

It depends on what gets skipped. If the task you're avoiding has a real deadline or someone waiting on it, doing easier useful work instead is still procrastination, with a nicer cover story. Studies of busy workers found that picking easy, quick tasks first felt productive but hurt output over time. It's fine when the top task can really wait.

Does structured procrastination actually work?

Nobody has run a study of Perry's method. It's a philosopher's observation, offered half as a joke. What research does support is the idea underneath it: procrastination is mostly about escaping a bad feeling, so you'll switch to almost anything that feels less bad. Whether that switch lands on useful work depends on how you set up your list.

Is structured procrastination the same as active procrastination?

No. Active procrastination, a term from Chu and Choi (2005), means deliberately waiting until the last minute because you work well under pressure. Structured procrastination keeps you busy with other real work while you avoid one task. Later researchers, Chowdhury and Pychyl (2018), argued that active procrastination is better described as purposeful delay than as procrastination.

Does structured procrastination work with ADHD?

It can, because it works with the urge to switch tasks rather than fighting it. Keep the list short and visible, make the lower tasks concrete, and never put a real deadline in the top slot. This is a planning trick, not treatment. If starting tasks is a struggle most days, it's worth raising with a doctor.

New here? Start with the reading order → Rather use paper? Grab a free printable.